As FHI 360’s Library Manager, I am often approached by colleagues asking me to recommend an appropriate journal for their manuscripts. A colleague recently asked for my opinion about a journal selection tool called EndNote Manuscript Matcher. The tool has been out for a few years but I (embarrassingly) had not had the chance to really delve into it. Could Manuscript Matcher be useful for me and my colleagues? I made a point to find out. Here I share what I learned and whether I recommend using it.